IN THIS LESSON

Before the rise of Classical Greece, there was a calamitous fall.

Topics discussed:

  • Basic details about the material

  • The running theme of the course

  • Historical context for understanding Iron Age Greece

For lesson transcripts, go to zencastr.com/The-Luxury-of-Virtue.

Focus Questions

  • Philosophy has taken many different forms throughout history, in what ways might the ancient philosophy covered in this class differ from contemporary philosophy?

  • How could one differentiate between the ethics of ancient philosophy and the type of ethics that is studied in academic philosophy today?

  • How might the physical environment facilitate the development and spread of ideas and culture?

  • What is a phonetic alphabet? How could this be advantageous?

  • Define the following religious concepts: ritual sacrifice, taking the auspices, oracles, mystery cults.

  • How did the growth and spread of Greek colonies lead to the development of specific socio-culutral practices, such as rational argumentation?

Glossary

Philosophical & Ethical Foundations

  • The Good Life – A central concern of ancient philosophy, referring to how one should live to achieve happiness, virtue, or fulfillment.

  • Ethics vs. Morality – Ethics, as we’ll be using the term, refers to the philosophical study of how one should live; this is juxtaposed with the modern notion of morality which is much narrower in scope, primarily focusing what actions are right or wrong (e.g., is abortion morally permissible?).

  • Therapeutic Philosophy – The idea that philosophy is not just about abstract reasoning but about transforming one’s life and achieving well-being. Stoicism and Epicureanism are prime examples.

  • Lifestyle Philosophy – A system of thought that provides not just a set of theoretical idea but also a way of living (e.g., Stoicism, Cynicism, Epicureanism).

  • Sages & Mystics – In ancient times, philosophers were sometimes seen as having secret knowledge or even supernatural abilities, blurring the line between philosophy, religion, and magic.

Historical & Cultural Context

  • Bronze Age (ca. 3000–1200 BCE) – The period of early civilizations in Greece, Mesopotamia, and Egypt, characterized by interconnected trade and political powers.

  • Bronze Age Collapse (ca. 1177 BCE) – A massive civilizational breakdown caused by climate change, famine, war, and disease, leading to the Greek Dark Age.

  • Greek Dark Age (ca. 1177–750 BCE) – A period of population decline, loss of literacy, and political fragmentation following the Bronze Age Collapse.

  • Mycenaeans – An early Greek civilization (ca. 1600–1100 BCE), known for its warrior culture and its role in shaping Greek mythology.

  • Apoikia – Greek settlements that were different from traditional colonies; instead of resorting to monarchy, these new communities utilized negotiation and political innovation to manage their social structures.

  • Poleis (plural of Polis)City-states that became the fundamental political units of Greece, known for their independence and constant warfare with each other.

  • Homeric Tradition – The oral storytelling tradition that gave rise to The Iliad and The Odyssey, later written down and used as educational and religious texts.

  • Hesiod’s Theogony – A work that describes the origins of the gods and the creation of the universe from chaos.

Language & Writing

  • Proto-Indo-European (PIE) – The hypothetical common ancestor of many languages, including Greek, Latin, Sanskrit, and English.

  • Linear B – The earliest form of written Greek, used by the Mycenaeans before the Greek Dark Age.

  • Phoenician Alphabet – A writing system adopted by the Greeks around 850 BCE, which was modified to include vowels, making it the first true phonetic alphabet.

  • Cultural Capital of Greek Language – Greek became the language of philosophy, science, medicine, and theology, influencing regions far beyond Greece itself.

Religion & Rituals

  • Greek Pantheon – The system of gods and goddesses worshiped by the Greeks, led by Zeus, often portrayed as powerful but tyrannical.

  • Household Gods – Various deities that were worshiped in Greek homes, including:

    • Hermes (guardian of roads and households).

    • Apollo (protector of the household).

    • Hestia (goddess of the hearth).

    • Zeus Ktesios (protector of property).

  • Ritual Sacrifice – A major part of Greek religion, where offerings were made to the gods, sometimes shared as a meal:

    • Communal Sacrifice – The most common type, where food was shared between humans and gods.

    • Burnt offering – The complete burning of an offering (e.g., human sacrifice), usually for some kind of atonement.

    • Sacramental Sacrifice – A mystical ritual in which participants consumed a god’s essence (e.g., Dionysian cults).

  • Taking the Auspices – A form of divination by observing birds, practiced by leaders before making important decisions.

  • OraclesPriestesses who delivered prophecies from the gods, often in cryptic or ambiguous messages (e.g., the Oracle of Delphi).

Mystery Cults & Religious Continuity

  • Mystery CultsSecret religious groups with hidden knowledge and initiation rituals, promising insight, transformation, or divine favor.

  • Göbekli Tepe (ca. 10,000–8,000 BCE) – One of the earliest known religious sites, possibly a site of pilgrimage and ritual sacrifice.

  • LSD Beer & Soma – Some scholars speculate that psychedelic substances were used in ancient religious rituals (e.g., Eleusinian Mysteries and Vedic Soma).

  • Pagan Continuity Hypothesis – The idea that early Christianity absorbed and transformed older pagan religious traditions, such as mystery cult rituals.

  • 1 Corinthians 11:27–30 – A passage in which Paul warns against improper participation in the Eucharist, possibly reflecting an older mystery cult tradition.

Poetry & Cultural Memory

  • The Iliad & The Odyssey – Epic poems attributed to Homer, blending history, myth, and moral lessons; essential reading for ancient Greeks.

  • Homeric Oral Tradition – The long-standing verbal storytelling tradition before the poems were written down around 500 BCE.

  • Immortality Through Song – The idea that heroes achieve eternal life through the preservation of their names in poetry and history.

Words You Might Not Know

  • Ethnos – A shared cultural identity among people, even if they are politically fragmented (e.g., Greek ethnos despite city-state rivalries).

  • Ambrosia – A sacred mixture (seeds, olive oil, and pure water) used in religious rituals, thought to be the food of the gods.

  • Transregional Gods – Deities worshiped across multiple regions, unlike later monotheistic gods who were tied to a specific people (e.g., Yahweh for the Israelites).

  • Skull Cult – An ancient practice where human skulls were venerated, possibly connected to ancestor worship or ritual sacrifice.

  • Atonement – A religious concept where a person makes amends for sin or wrongdoing, often through sacrifice.

  • HegemonyDominance of one state or culture over others, such as Greek cultural influence across the Mediterranean.

  • Martial ValorBravery in battle, considered a key virtue in Homeric society.

  • Anachronistic – Applying modern ideas to historical periods where they don’t belong (e.g., calling ancient philosophers “scientists”).

  • Raiding Culture – A common practice in early societies, where groups survived through piracy, theft, and warfare (e.g., the revised view of the Trojan War).

For other questions…

Reading List

Erich Cline, 1177 B.C.: The Year Civilization Collapsed: Revised and Updated.

Erich Cline, After 1177 B.C.: The Survival of Civilizations.

Roderick Beaton, The Greeks: A Global History.

David Anthony, The Horse, the Wheel, and Language: How Bronze-Age Riders from the Eurasian Steppes Shaped the Modern World.

Michael Shenefelt and Heidi White, If A, Then B: How the World Discovered Logic.

Brian Muraresku, The Immortality Key: The Secret History of the Religion with No Name.